Papa Nick’s I is a family Italian Restaurant, since 1992. They serve many Italian favorites, including pizzas, pastas, appetizers, calzones, subs and salads, plus Greek entrees, everything which is homemade. Calzones are the best in town!
“While out YELPING we found Papa Nick’s in Sarasota Florida. We enjoyed the restaurant so much we have now visited a total of 3 times. My spouse had the Pizza and I the Papa Nick’s Stromboli which was loaded with all the fixins. The bread and salad is also outstanding especially when you add Papp’s homemade Ranch Dressing. Some friends had the meat ball sandwich and fries and overall Papa’s is a real gem. Hard to get a five star from me but this restaurant rises to the level. Just off of I-75 and Fruitville Road.” – Robert N.
“This is one of those homey little pizza/Italian restaurants often found in strip shopping malls in the Eastern part of the US but not as common in the Midwest where we live. What distinguishes this place is extremely good food at very low prices for the region. Stuffed shells were about the best I’ve ever had and my partner raved about the sauce on his pasta. Very friendly service. A good buy away from the pricey areas of downtown Sarasota. Highly recommended.” – John F.
“Love the food here! Have breakfast here almost everyday for the amazing french toast and would recommend the chicken pita or spinach pizza for lunch and dinner. Both are delicious! Prices are very reasonable and service is great!” – Shelby W.
“My wife and I stopped in knowing nothing about this spot. There was a good crowd at 1pm for lunch. With a menu right in the window and a large special board just inside we liked what we saw and entered. We were greeted immediately and told we could sit anywhere we liked. We were greeted pleasantly by our waitress and given water. I ordered a Gyro and fries , my wife a Greek salad and chicken , our food was delicious, this bill under 15 dollars. The atmosphere was very nice for a strip mall location. Pride of ownership, outstanding food and superb value make this a no brainer for a return trip.” – Snorkler09
Address:4940 Fruitville Road Sarasota, FL 34232 941-377-4753 Papa Nick’s Facebook Page